Colorado Medicare Advantage Plans Made Simple

Colorado Medicare Advantage Plans: Your 2025 Guide

Medicare Advantage plans in Colorado offer comprehensive healthcare coverage that combines hospital insurance (Part A), medical insurance (Part B), and usually prescription drug coverage (Part D) into one convenient plan. Here's what you need to know:

Available Plans

120 plans (down from 132 in 2024)

Average Monthly Premium

$12.20 (decreased from $15.11 in 2024)

$0 Premium Plan Availability

99.7% of Medicare-eligible Coloradans

Top-Rated Plans

UnitedHealthcare (5-star), Aetna (4.5-star)

Enrollment

Over 1 million Medicare beneficiaries

Medicare Advantage plans in Colorado offer more than just basic Medicare coverage. These plans typically include:

• Prescription drug coverage (Part D)
• Extra benefits like dental, vision, hearing, and fitness programs
• Out-of-pocket maximums for financial protection
• Coordinated care through provider networks

For 2025, Colorado residents have access to 120 Medicare Advantage plans, with premiums averaging $12.20 per month. Nearly all Medicare-eligible Coloradans (99.7%) can access at least one $0-premium plan.



I'm Kelsey Mackley, an insurance specialist at Kelmeg & Associates, Inc., where I've helped hundreds of Colorado residents steer Medicare Advantage plans in Colorado to find coverage that matches their healthcare needs and budget. My expertise allows me to simplify complex Medicare options into clear, actionable guidance for our clients.

Staying active is easier with fitness benefits like SilverSneakers®, included in most plans. This popular program gives you access to over 15,000 fitness locations nationwide, group exercise classes designed for seniors, and online fitness resources.

Many plans go even further, offering transportation to medical appointments, meal delivery after hospital stays, in-home support services, $0 copay telehealth visits, acupuncture, chiropractic care, and even allowances for groceries and utilities in some Special Needs Plans.

Star Ratings & Top-Rated Carriers

Not all Medicare Advantage plans are created equal, which is why the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) rates them on a 1-5 star scale. These ratings help you identify high-performing plans.

For 2025, Colorado Medicare beneficiaries have access to excellence with UnitedHealthcare offering 5-star rated plans. Additionally, both Aetna and UnitedHealthcare provide 4.5-star rated plans in the state.

These ratings aren't arbitrary – they're based on over 40 quality measures across five categories: preventive care and screenings, managing chronic conditions, member experience, complaint handling, and customer service. Higher-rated plans typically deliver better care and higher member satisfaction.

One special advantage of 5-star plans: you can switch to them at any time during the year through a special enrollment period, not just during the typical enrollment windows!

Budgeting for Premiums & Out-of-Pocket Costs

When planning your healthcare budget, look beyond the monthly premium. Every Medicare Advantage plan in Colorado includes a maximum out-of-pocket limit – the most you'll pay for covered services in a year. This crucial financial safeguard ranges from about $3,500 to $8,850 in Colorado plans. Once you reach this limit, your plan pays 100% for covered services for the rest of the year.

If prescription costs are a concern, you might qualify for Extra Help (also called Low-Income Subsidy or LIS). This program reduces or eliminates drug premiums and deductibles while lowering prescription copays. For 2024, individuals with income below $21,870 ($29,580 for married couples) and limited assets may qualify.

Colorado also offers Medicare Savings Programs that help pay Medicare premiums and sometimes other costs like deductibles and coinsurance. These programs – QMB, SLMB, QI, and QDWI – have varying income and asset limits, with Colorado's limits often more generous than federal standards.

Good news about the dreaded "donut hole" – the Medicare Part D coverage gap has been closed. You'll never pay more than 25% for covered brand-name and generic drugs during this phase. However, if you take multiple medications, consider plans with additional gap coverage to keep your costs predictable throughout the year.

At Kelmeg & Associates, we've helped hundreds of Coloradans steer these options to find the perfect balance of coverage and cost. The right plan can save you thousands while providing better benefits than you might expect!

Comparing & Choosing Medicare Advantage Plans in Colorado

Finding your way through 120 Medicare Advantage plans in Colorado for 2025 might feel overwhelming at first. It's like standing at the base of one of our beautiful Colorado mountains the view is impressive, but you need a clear path to the top!

Comparing Medicare Advantage Plans in Colorado Step-by-Step

Let's break this journey down into manageable steps, just like we would for a mountain hike.

First, gather your medications list. Think of this as packing your essential gear note all prescription names, dosages, and how often you take them. Don't forget to include your preferred pharmacy. This information is your compass when comparing drug coverage between plans.

Next, map out your healthcare providers. Your doctors are like trusted trail guides you want to keep them on your journey if possible. Write down your primary care physician, specialists, preferred hospitals, and any labs or imaging centers you regularly visit. Checking if these providers are in-network could save you significant money.

Consider what matters most to you in healthcare coverage. Are you willing to pay higher monthly premiums for lower costs when you receive care? Do you value the freedom to see providers outside your network? Perhaps specific benefits like comprehensive dental coverage or hearing aids are essential for your quality of life. Maybe you travel frequently and need coverage that travels with you.

The Medicare Plan Finder at Medicare.gov is your trail map for this journey. Enter your ZIP code, county, medications, and preferred pharmacy to see plans custom to your needs. You can filter by plan type, sort by costs, and compare star ratings and extra benefits side by side.

Don't be fooled by looking at monthly premiums alone that's like judging a hiking trail solely by its starting point. Instead, calculate your estimated annual costs by multiplying the premium by 12 and adding expected drug costs, typical copays, and deductibles. Sometimes a plan with a higher monthly premium actually costs less overall because it offers better coverage for your specific needs.

Quality matters in healthcare just as much as it does in hiking gear. Check plan star ratings think of 4-5 stars as well-maintained trails, 3-3.5 stars as average paths, and below 3 stars as potentially rough terrain. Colorado is fortunate to have several 4.5 and 5-star plans available for 2025.

Understand how each plan's network restrictions might affect your care. HMO plans generally limit you to in-network providers except for emergencies, while PPO plans offer more flexibility but at higher costs for out-of-network care. Consider how these limitations align with your healthcare needs and travel habits.

Once you've selected your plan, enrollment is straightforward. You can sign up online through Medicare.gov, by calling 1-800-MEDICARE, directly through the insurance company, or with help from a licensed insurance agent who knows the terrain.

Online & Local Tools to Help You Decide

You don't have to steer Medicare Advantage plans in Colorado alone. Think of these resources as your hiking buddies, offering support along the way:

Medicare.gov serves as your comprehensive guidebook, with plan comparison tools, provider lookups, and educational resources all in one place.

The Colorado SHIP (State Health Insurance Assistance Program) offers free, unbiased Medicare counseling like having a personal guide who knows every trail in the state. They provide one-on-one assistance with plan selection, help understanding benefits, support with claims issues, and guidance on appeals. Reach them at 1-888-696-7213 when you need that personal touch.

The Senior Health Care & Medicare Assistance program through the Colorado Division of Insurance provides Colorado-specific resources and consumer protection information. They're especially helpful if you encounter problems with insurance companies.

At Kelmeg & Associates, Inc., our Medicare Licensed Insurance Agents in Colorado are like experienced trail guides who know every path and viewpoint. We provide personalized plan comparisons custom to your specific situation, offer expertise on local options, help determine if you qualify for money-saving programs, and assist with enrollment. Best of all, our services come at no additional cost to you we're compensated by the insurance companies when you enroll.

We're also proud to offer our Medicare Resource Center where you can find additional information and guidance on your Medicare journey.

Finding the right Medicare Advantage plan in Colorado doesn't have to feel like scaling a fourteener without a map. With the right resources and guidance, you can find a plan that offers the coverage, benefits, and value that perfectly match your healthcare needs and budget.

Assistance, Special Circumstances & FAQs

Navigating Medicare doesn't have to feel overwhelming. Let's walk through some helpful resources and answers to common questions about Medicare Advantage plans in Colorado that might make your journey a bit smoother.

Extra Help and Medicare Savings Programs

Are prescription costs stretching your budget thin? You're not alone. Many Colorado seniors qualify for financial assistance but don't know it.

Applying for Extra Help

Extra Help can save you thousands on prescription medications. For 2024, you might qualify if your income falls below $21,870 for individuals or $29,580 for married couples, with assets under $16,660 for individuals or $33,240 for married couples.

Applying is simpler than you might think:

1. Visit SSA.gov to apply online
2. Call Social Security at 1-800-772-1213
3. Stop by your local Social Security office
4. Work with your State Medicaid office

I recently helped a client save over $300 monthly on insulin and heart medications through Extra Help. Don't leave this money on the table!

Medicare Savings Programs (MSP) Income Limits

Colorado's Medicare Savings Programs can help cover your Medicare costs when money is tight. For 2024, here's approximately what you need to qualify:

For QMB (Qualified Medicare Beneficiary) which covers premiums, deductibles, and copayments, income limits are around $1,235 monthly for individuals and $1,663 for couples.

The SLMB (Specified Low-Income Medicare Beneficiary) program helps with Part B premiums only, with limits of about $1,478 for individuals and $1,992 for couples.

For QI (Qualifying Individual) assistance with Part B premiums, limits are roughly $1,660 for individuals and $2,239 for couples.

Colorado often has more generous asset limits than federal standards, so don't assume you won't qualify without checking first.

Special Circumstances

Life is rarely one-size-fits-all, and neither is Medicare coverage.

Employer & Retiree Coverage

Still working or have retiree health benefits? Smart move to compare them with Medicare Advantage plans in Colorado before making any decisions.

Always chat with your benefits administrator first—joining a Medicare Advantage plan might impact your employer coverage. Request a "creditable coverage" letter for your records, as this documentation can help you avoid penalties down the road.

One of my clients nearly lost valuable retiree coverage by enrolling in a Medicare Advantage plan without checking first. A quick conversation with her HR department saved her from a costly mistake.

VA & TRICARE Rules

Veterans and military families have unique considerations when exploring Medicare options.

If you have VA Benefits, you can absolutely pair them with a Medicare Advantage plan. Your VA benefits cover care at VA facilities, while your Medicare Advantage plan gives you access to non-VA providers. Just remember, you can't use VA benefits to cover Medicare Advantage copays or deductibles.

For those with TRICARE For Life, know that it works seamlessly with Original Medicare but not with Medicare Advantage. If you choose a Medicare Advantage plan, you'll need to use your plan's network providers. Many of my clients with TRICARE find that their existing coverage provides better value than available Medicare Advantage options.

Late-Enrollment Penalties

Nobody likes paying penalties, especially ones that stick around for life.

The Part B Penalty adds 10% to your standard Part B premium for each 12-month period you could have enrolled but didn't. This isn't a one-time fee—it continues for as long as you have Part B.

The Part D Penalty adds 1% of the national base beneficiary premium ($34.70 in 2024) times the number of months you went without creditable drug coverage. This extra amount gets tacked onto your monthly premium indefinitely.

Enrolling when first eligible or maintaining creditable coverage is the simplest way to avoid these costly penalties.

Drug Coverage & Formularies

Understanding how your medications are covered can save you hundreds—sometimes thousands—of dollars annually with Medicare Advantage plans in Colorado.

Formulary Tiers

Think of formulary tiers as a medication pricing menu. Most plans organize drugs into five tiers with increasing costs:

Tier 1 offers preferred generics with the lowest copays—often just a few dollars. Tier 2 includes non-preferred generics, while Tier 3 covers preferred brand-name drugs. Tier 4 medications are non-preferred brand-name drugs, and Tier 5 includes specialty medications with the highest costs.

I always recommend checking your specific medications' tier placement before enrolling in any plan. A drug's tier can make a dramatic difference in your monthly costs.

Step Therapy and Prior Authorization

Some plans use management techniques that might affect how quickly you can access certain medications:

Step therapy requires trying more affordable medications before covering pricier options. Prior authorization means your doctor must get plan approval before certain medications are covered. Quantity limits restrict how much medication you can receive in a specific timeframe.

While these rules can be frustrating, understanding them helps avoid surprise pharmacy counter sticker shock.

Preferred Pharmacy Networks

Where you fill your prescriptions matters almost as much as what you're filling. Many plans offer significantly lower copays at preferred pharmacies—sometimes $0 for generic medications. Standard network pharmacies typically charge higher copays, while non-network pharmacies may not be covered at all.

I recently helped a client save over $200 quarterly just by switching to her plan's preferred pharmacy for her regular prescriptions.

Coverage Gap Strategies

The coverage gap (or "donut hole") isn't as daunting as it once was, but costs can still add up. Consider asking about generic alternatives, checking if your plan offers additional gap coverage, exploring pharmaceutical assistance programs, or applying for Extra Help if eligible.

Reporting Medicare Fraud in Colorado

Medicare fraud isn't just wrong—it drives up costs for everyone. If something seems suspicious, trust your instincts and report it.

The Colorado Senior Medicare Patrol (SMP) at 1-800-503-5190 helps identify and report Medicare errors, fraud, and abuse. The Colorado Division of Insurance (1-303-894-7490 or 1-800-930-3745) handles complaints about insurance companies or agents. You can also contact the CMS Fraud Hotline directly at 1-800-MEDICARE.

When reporting, provide as many details as possible—dates, provider information, and descriptions of the suspicious activity all help investigators address the issue.

Frequently Asked Questions

What happens if I miss my enrollment window?

If you miss your Initial Enrollment Period, you'll generally need to wait until the General Enrollment Period (January 1-March 31) to sign up for Original Medicare, with coverage starting July 1. And yes, those late enrollment penalties we discussed earlier may apply.

For Medicare Advantage plans in Colorado, missing the Annual Election Period (October 15-December 7) typically means waiting until the next AEP unless you qualify for a Special Enrollment Period due to life events like moving or losing other coverage.

Can I switch plans during the Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period?

Absolutely! If you're already enrolled in a Medicare Advantage plan, you get a second chance to make a change during the Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period (January 1-March 31). You can switch to a different Medicare Advantage plan or return to Original Medicare and add a standalone Part D plan.

Just note that this period doesn't allow those on Original Medicare to join a Medicare Advantage plan—that's what the fall Annual Election Period is for.

Are $0-premium plans really free?

While "$0 premium" sounds like "free," it's important to understand the full picture. These plans don't charge an additional monthly premium beyond your Part B premium ($174.70 for most people in 2024), but you'll still have cost-sharing when you receive care.

Think of it like a restaurant with no cover charge—you still pay for what you order inside. These plans often have higher copays or coinsurance than plans with premiums, and network restrictions apply.

That said, $0-premium plans can offer excellent value for many people, especially those who are relatively healthy or budget-conscious. The true cost depends on your personal healthcare needs and usage.

Conclusion

Navigating Medicare Advantage plans in Colorado can feel like trying to find your way through a maze. But with the right guidance, you can find a plan that fits your healthcare needs like a well-worn pair of hiking boots comfortable, reliable, and suited to Colorado's unique terrain.



With 120 plans available for 2025, you have plenty of options. Think of your search like planning a trip through our beautiful Rocky Mountains you need the right map and sometimes a friendly guide who knows the territory.

When comparing plans, remember to look beyond just the monthly premium. A $0 premium plan might seem attractive at first glance like a "free" trail pass but you'll want to check what's waiting around the bend in terms of deductibles, copays, and out-of-pocket maximums. The true cost of your healthcare journey includes all these landmarks along the way.

Your relationship with your doctors matters too. Before setting out with a new plan, verify that your trusted healthcare providers are in-network. It's like making sure your favorite mountain lodge is open before planning your stay.

For those who take medications regularly, reviewing drug formularies is essential. Each plan's prescription coverage is unique some might cover your medications at $5 a month while others might charge $50 or not cover them at all. This difference alone can determine whether a plan is right for you.

Many Medicare Advantage plans in Colorado include extra benefits that Original Medicare doesn't cover dental care for that confident smile, vision coverage for enjoying Colorado's spectacular views, hearing benefits to catch every word of conversation with friends, and fitness programs to keep you active on our trails and in our communities.

At Kelmeg & Associates, Inc., we believe everyone deserves a knowledgeable companion on their Medicare journey. Our team of licensed insurance specialists serves neighbors throughout Colorado, from Lafayette to Broomfield, Boulder to Adams County, and we do it at no cost to you. We're your neighbors who understand Colorado's unique healthcare landscape.

We take the time to listen to your healthcare story your doctors, your medications, your priorities and help you find the plan that provides the best value and coverage for your unique situation. It's like having a friend who knows all the best trails and viewpoints.

For personalized assistance with Medicare Advantage plans in Colorado, reach out to our team at Kelmeg & Associates, Inc. today. We're here to help you steer your Medicare journey with the confidence of a Colorado native on a familiar mountain path.

More info about Medicare services