If your Colorado group health plan renews January 1, review the renewal as soon as it arrives. Compare the rate change, check whether your current plans are still offered, look at Colorado Option and alternative plan designs, revisit how much you contribute, and set a decision deadline that leaves time for employee enrollment. Waiting until mid-December leaves little room to shop or adjust.
For many Colorado small businesses, the group health renewal lands in the same weeks as year-end payroll, holiday schedules, and budget planning. It is easy to sign the renewal and move on. But a renewal is also the one time each year when you can change plans, contributions, or carriers without disruption. This guide covers what to review. For a broader overview, see our employer group benefits in Colorado guide.
What should I look at first on my renewal?
Start with the rate change and the plan list. Note the percentage increase for each plan, whether any plans you offer are being discontinued or changed, and whether benefits like deductibles and copays are different next year. A renewal with a modest rate change can still hide a benefit change that matters to employees.
| Renewal item | What to check | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Rate change by plan | Percentage and dollar change per employee | Drives your budget and employee contributions |
| Plan availability | Whether current plans continue | Discontinued plans force a change |
| Benefit changes | Deductibles, copays, out-of-pocket maximums | Employees feel these at the doctor |
| Network | Whether key doctors and hospitals remain | Network changes cause the most complaints |
| Prescription coverage | Formulary changes for common drugs | Affects employees with ongoing prescriptions |
| Participation rules | Minimum participation and contribution | Affects eligibility to keep the group plan |
What options do Colorado small businesses have at renewal?
You can renew as is, change plans with the same carrier, add a second plan option, move to another carrier, or change your contribution strategy. Colorado Option plans are also available in the small-group market, with standardized designs that can make comparison easier. Our post on Colorado Option health plans for 2027 explains how those plans work.
How should I think about employer contributions?
Contribution strategy is often a bigger lever than the plan itself. Some employers contribute a fixed percentage of the employee-only premium. Others contribute a fixed dollar amount, which keeps the budget predictable when rates rise. Offering a lower-premium base plan and a richer buy-up plan can give employees a choice while keeping the employer's cost steady. Check the carrier's minimum contribution and participation rules before you change anything.
How long does a renewal decision take?
Longer than most owners expect. After you choose, employees need time to review options and make elections, and the carrier needs time to process them before January 1. Plan backward from your effective date.
- Review the renewal and gather quotes as soon as it arrives.
- Decide on plans and contributions with time to spare before mid-December.
- Share options with employees and hold a short open enrollment.
- Submit elections to the carrier by its deadline.
- Send ID card and payroll deduction details before January 1.
What should I tell employees during renewal?
Keep it simple. Explain what is changing, what is staying the same, how much their paycheck deduction will be, and the deadline to make choices. A one-page summary and a short meeting usually work better than forwarding the carrier's documents. Employees with ongoing treatment should check that their doctors and prescriptions are covered under any new plan.
What are common questions about small business renewals?
When do Colorado small group renewals arrive?
Carriers typically send renewals before the renewal date. For January 1 renewals, that usually means the fall. Review as soon as yours arrives.
Can I change carriers at renewal?
Yes. Renewal is the natural time to change carriers or plans, as long as you meet the new carrier's participation and contribution rules.
Are Colorado Option plans available for small groups?
Yes. The Colorado Option includes standardized small-group plans, which can be compared alongside other group plans.
What if I miss the renewal deadline?
Your plan typically renews as offered. Making changes later may be limited until the next renewal, so act early.
Can I offer more than one plan to employees?
Many carriers allow two or more plan options. A base plan and a buy-up plan is a common structure.
Does a broker cost extra for a group renewal review?
Licensed brokers such as Kelmeg & Associates are typically paid by carriers, so a renewal review does not add cost to your plan.
Where can Colorado employers get a renewal review?
Kelmeg & Associates helps Colorado small businesses review renewals, compare employer group benefits, and communicate changes to employees. Call (303) 466-9575 or book a consultation as soon as your renewal arrives.
This article is for general educational purposes only and is not insurance, financial, tax, or legal advice. Plan availability, rates, participation and contribution rules, and benefits vary by carrier and group. Confirm details with the carrier or a licensed insurance broker before making changes. Kelmeg & Associates, Inc. is a licensed Colorado insurance brokerage.

